WORCESTER, MA — The City of Worcester has been dealt a costly legal setback in a long-running dispute with the neighboring town of Holden.
On Monday, the Massachusetts Appeals Court upheld a Superior Court ruling ordering Worcester to pay more than $26.5 million for overcharging Holden on sewer fees — a total that could climb to nearly $30 million by next year once interest is added.
The unanimous decision from Associate Justices Maureen E. Walsh, Paul Hart Smyth, and William J. Meade affirmed the 2023 judgment by Superior Court Judge James Manitsas. His ruling required Worcester to pay Holden $26,525,786 plus 12% annual post-judgment interest. If the city does not pay in 2025, the balance will reach about $29.9 million.
A Worcester spokesperson said the city has received the decision and is “reviewing its options for appeal.” Holden officials did not immediately comment.
How the dispute began
The conflict traces back more than a decade. In 2013, Holden sued Worcester, claiming it was being overcharged roughly $1 million per year to use Worcester’s sewer system. Town officials argued that the rates amounted to an unconstitutional tax and were far higher than what Worcester residents paid.
A Worcester jury sided with Holden in 2022, finding that the city had overcharged the town by more than $10 million. The jury awarded $14.6 million in damages. Judge Manitsas later upheld that verdict, tacking on $2.2 million in costs and $11.3 million in pre-judgment interest, bringing Worcester’s liability to more than $26 million.
Worcester attempted to overturn the ruling, arguing that a 2000 Sewer Use Agreement gave the city the contractual right to set the fees. Both the Superior Court and the Appeals Court rejected that defense, instead siding with Holden’s claim that Worcester was unjustly enriched.
What’s next
The ruling means Worcester is now on the hook for tens of millions of dollars — and the longer the city delays payment, the more it will owe. The city has not yet confirmed whether it will pursue a further appeal.
For Holden, the decision represents a major victory in a legal battle that has stretched over 12 years. For Worcester, it marks a multimillion-dollar liability that could impact city finances for years to come.
Get Worcester, MA news first. Follow Worcester County News on Facebook for breaking news, events and local spotlights from every town in Worcester County.
Follow us on Facebook








